Making Disciples of Jesus to the Glory of God

NYC Annual Report

Pastoral Letter

Photo Coming Soon

Friends and Supporters,

I am deeply grateful for your partnership with Citylight New York. Because of your prayers and generosity, we are making disciples of Jesus for the glory of God in New York City.

After you have suffered a little while, [God] will himself restore, confirm, strengthen, and establish you. (1 Peter 5:10)

This verse beautifully captures what the Lord has done in our family and church over the past year.

When we arrived in New York, our vision was simple: plant our family, plant a core team, plant the church, and—by God's grace—plant more churches. Today, phase one is complete, and as our core team approaches twenty people, we are prayerfully aiming to complete phase two by Easter 2026.

One year ago, we were the size of a small bible study. We were not yet gathering weekly for worship, no one had come to faith through our ministry, and our family had been in the city only four months.

Today, because of your support:

  • Our family is thriving in New York
  • Over twenty people are regularly involved in the church
  • Sixteen are committed members
  • We've celebrated one year of weekly worship gatherings
  • We've baptized one new believer and seen others recommit to Christ
  • We launched a second citygroup in downtown Manhattan

Thank you for walking with us through prayer and generosity. We look forward to all the Lord will do through our partnership in 2026.

With gratitude in Christ,

Timothy Shutes
Church Planter, Citylight New York

2025 Stories

Overcoming Our First Gospel Goodbyes

Our first six months of ministry in New York City culminated in an Easter gathering of 24 people—including our first new believer. Just two months later, however, ten regular attendees and six core team members were called by God to move out of the city.

In that season, the church leaned deeply into prayer and community. The Lord used this time of loss to unite us and renew our commitment to seek Him together.

"My God will supply every need of yours according to his riches in glory in Christ Jesus." (Philippians 4:19)

And He did.

Downtown Citygroup Launch

It wasn't long after these gospel goodbyes that the Lord began adding to our number. Through several providential connections, we met young adults—mostly in their mid-20s—living in downtown Manhattan.

Though their stories differed, they shared a common thread: they had been disconnected from church and sensed a call to re-engage in a gospel-centered community.

From these relationships, we launched a new downtown Citygroup that now gathers 8–12 young adults each week for meals, fellowship, Bible study, and prayer.

New Covenant Members

Recently, we welcomed three new covenant members from our downtown Citygroup, with more expected in the coming months.

We are prayerfully aiming to reach 20 covenant members by Easter 2026.

New Worship Space & Citylight Kids Launch

Worship gathering at Hephzibah House

For nearly a year, our worship gatherings met in our living room. While we cherished that season as a house church, we are grateful to now gather at Hephzibah House on West 75th Street.

This space has been a gift to our church, especially as it allows us to offer Citylight Kids. Each week, our children hear the gospel in ways designed just for them.

We're thankful for this provision and hopeful to outgrow the space and move to a morning service later this year.

100+ Meals & Gospel Conversations

Community meal gathering

Over the past year, our church has shared more than 100 meals together. As our church has grown, so has our commitment to prayer, hospitality, and personal evangelism.

Our members regularly pray for friends and coworkers who don't know Jesus and look for natural ways to share Christ:

  • One member is reading the Gospel of John with three unbelieving friends
  • Another is walking with a Columbia student struggling with addiction
  • Others regularly participate in neighborhood outreach through shared meals
  • A recent guest spent hours discussing the gospel with a covenant member at a local restaurant

Our ultimate desire is simple: to see many come to know Jesus as Lord through faithful presence, shared meals, and the clear proclamation of the gospel.

Our Journey

Phase 1

Complete

Plant the Family

Funding Goal: $400k

  • Moved to NYC, secured housing, enrolled kids in school
  • Financially prepared for Tim to transition to full-time pastoring
  • Opportunity secured for long-term housing via apartment purchase
  • Funded at $400k goal

Phase 2

Current

Plant the Core Team

Funding Goal: $1.0M

  • 100 meals together
  • Launched first Citygroup in uptown Manhattan
  • Baptize first new believer
  • Add second citygroup
  • Gather 20 committed members
  • Demonstrate growth in prayer, evangelism and hospitality
  • Funded at $1.0M goal

Phase 3

Plant the Church

Funding Goal: $3.0M

  • Grow Core Team into a 40 person Launch Team
  • Add 3rd and 4th citygroups
  • Establish mercy partners
  • Begin early elder training program
  • Launch marketing and public gathering
  • Recruit 3 vocational ministers
  • Baptize at least 5 new believers
  • Funded at $3.0M goal

Phase 4

Plant More Churches

Funding Goal: Self-sustaining

  • Install at least two additional elders
  • Establish long-term facility
  • Launch church planting residency
  • Grow to 150+ worshipers
  • Plant more churches in NYC
  • Send missionaries around the world
  • Become financially self-sustaining

Financial Update

Looking Ahead

We are raising $1 million in combined internal and external support to fund the next 18–24 months of ministry. This will allow us to:

  • Grow our core team
  • Set a public launch date
  • Expand to four citygroups
  • Invest in facilities
  • Recruit evangelists
  • Deepen theological formation
  • Sustain the ongoing work of the church

New York City presents a uniquely long and costly onramp for church planting. Our aim is not quick growth, but the long-term establishment of a healthy church that will endure for decades. With only 3–5% of the population identifying as Christian, millions in our metro area still need the gospel—and we believe the harvest is plentiful.

Thank you for your partnership in the gospel.

2025 Planned 2025 Actual 2026 Planned
Income $400,000 $383,439 $650,000
Expenses $321,520 $243,275 $559,130
Income Expenses
2025 Planned $400,000 $321,520
2025 Actual $383,439 $243,275
2026 Planned $650,000 $559,130

Copyright 2026